Can vs.
May vs. Shall – Key Differences
1. "Can" – Ability, Possibility, Permission
·
Ability (Physical or Mental Skills)
o
I can swim very fast. (Skill to swim
quickly)
o
She can speak three languages fluently.
(Ability to speak three languages)
·
Possibility (When Circumstances Allow
It)
o
We can go to the park if the weather is
nice. (If the weather is good, we can go)
o
You can buy this book online. (It is
possible to buy the book online)
·
Permission (Informal Situations)
o
Can I leave early today? (Is it okay to
leave early?)
o
You can take my car if you need it. (I
allow you to use my car)
o
⚠️ In formal and polite situations,
"may" is better for permission.
2. "May" – Permission, Probability
·
Permission (Polite and Formal)
o
May I use your phone? (Polite way to
ask for permission)
o
You may leave the table now. (Formal
permission to leave)
·
Probability (Usually for the Future)
o
It may rain tomorrow. (A chance of
rain)
o
She may be at home now. (Maybe she is
at home)
·
"May" sounds more polite and
formal than "can."
3. "Shall" – A Signal for Action
·
Military Commands and Official Orders
o
"On my command, you shall
proceed." (Command to move)
o
"The team shall begin the operation at
0600 hours." (Official order)
·
Sports and Ceremonial Events
o
"At the sound of the bell, the runners
shall start." (Runners start at the bell)
o
"The orchestra shall begin playing as
soon as the conductor raises his baton." (Action upon a cue)
·
Meetings, Voting, and Ceremonies
o
"After the chairman’s speech, we shall
proceed with the voting." (Action following speech)
o
"At my signal, the guests shall enter
the hall." (Guests enter when signaled)
·
Official Instructions and Action Plans
o
"The delegates shall take their seats
before the conference begins." (Obligation before event)
o
"Once the documents are signed, we
shall move to the next stage." (Next step follows signing)
Fill in the blanks with CAN, MAY, or SHALL (as a
signal for action).
- You ___
take my book if you need it.
- ___ I
leave the table now?
- The
soldiers ___ begin the attack at sunrise.
- If you
practice a lot, you ___ become a great musician.
- We ___
proceed with the presentation after the manager arrives.
- He ___
be at work now, but I’m not sure.
- ___ you
swim when you were five years old?
- ___ I
open the window? It’s quite hot in here.
- The guests
___ enter the hall after the announcement.
- You ___
call me later if you have any questions.
- The
ceremony ___ start as soon as the director arrives.
- We ___
go for a walk if it doesn’t rain.
- Students
___ leave the classroom after finishing the test.
- You ___
not use your phone in the library.
- The
orchestra ___ begin playing when the conductor signals.
- He ___
be late because of traffic.
- I ___
help you with your homework if you want.
- The
runners ___ start running at the sound of the whistle.
- ___ I
borrow your pen for a moment?
- The
delegates ___ take their seats before the conference starts.
- He ___
lift very heavy weights at the gym.
- ___ you
help me move this table?
- The
teachers ___ meet in the staff room after lunch.
- You ___
take a day off if you don’t feel well.
- The
team ___ begin their training at 8 AM sharp.
- ___ I
ask you something personal?
- If you
want to improve your English, you ___ practice more.
- ___ I
have another cup of coffee, please?
- The
musicians ___ start playing after the host introduces them.
- If you
work hard, you ___ achieve your dreams.
- The
workers ___ return to their stations after the break.
- You ___
drive at 18 years old in many countries.
- The
bell rings, and the students ___ enter the classroom.
- The
voting ___ start as soon as the chairman finishes his speech.
- We ___
go to the museum after lunch if we have time.
- ___ I
sit here, or is this seat taken?
- The
pilot ___ take off after receiving permission from the tower.
- You ___
speak loudly in the library. It's a quiet place.
- The
guests ___ leave after the final speech.
- The
leader ___ give the signal, and the march will begin.
Answer Key:
- can
- May
- shall
- can
- shall
- may
- Could
(but "Can" in informal speech)
- May
- shall
- can
- shall
- can
- may
- can’t
- shall
- may
- can
- shall
- May
- shall
- can
- Can
- shall
- may
- shall
- May
- can
- May
- shall
- can
- shall
- can
- shall
- shall
- can
- May
- shall
- can’t
- may
- shall
Немає коментарів:
Дописати коментар